LIGHT-HEARTED START TO NEW GRAVENHURST COUNCIL TERM SHOWS EASY-GOING NEXT FOUR YEARS UNDER FISCALLY CONSERVATIVE MAYOR JEFF WATSON

Mark Clairmont | MuskokaTODAY.com OPINION

Subscribe: E-transfer $30 to news@muskokatoday.com

GRAVENHURST — With two thirds of council members new, it’s not surprising most were nervous when they took the oath of office here last night at the Opera House.

“Repeat after me …” was easier said than done, as CAO Scott Lucas read a few lines to each one at a time — including starting with new Mayor Jeff Watson.

“Can you speak a little slower — my mother has Alzheimer’s,” said Ward 2 councillor Dave Kellam, who admitted after his mother wasn’t actually there — or alive; though she did pass on with dementia.

Even Penny Varney, a veteran of these swearing ins, agreed Lucas made the sound-bites a little longer than other years.

Six of the nine on Gravenhurst’s new council are new this term, with Mayor Jeff Watson back a third time, along with, left, Penny Varney, Sandy Cairns, Tina Kilbourne, Jaden Hollingshead, Carol Anne Lemoine, Heidi Welker, Dave Kellam and Randy Jorgensen. PHOTOS Mark Clairmont MuskokaTODAY.com

Stumbles aside, it made for a light-hearted start to the evening and the first meeting of the new 2026-30 council term as more than 200 family, friends and constituents gathered to wish them well in their four-year political journey. And included some council board appointments.

This week has been a busy one for new and returning politicians. With Muskoka Lakes holding their 11 a.m. inaugural meeting yesterday morning, which acclaimed Mayor Peter Kelley admitted that only about 50 attended. Lake of Bays councillors had also gathered an hour earlier at 10 a.m.

Bracebridge’s first term meeting is tonight at 5:30 p.m., at the Muskoka Lumber Community Centre. Huntsville and Georgian Bay held theirs Monday morning. The election was Oct. 26.

Rookie councillor Kilbourne deputy mayor

In the Gateway to Muskoka, the first surprise of the night was the appointment of rookie Ward 5 councillor Tina Kilbourne as deputy mayor. She said she wasn’t surprised, having been told prior.

Randy Jorgensen, acclaimed in Ward 4, will be the “acting mayor” — or third in line to the top — if Watson and Kilbourne ever become unavailable.

Their council is comprised of:

  • Jeff Watson – Mayor (1,869 votes)
  • Heidi Welker – Ward 1 Councillor (407 votes)
  • David Kellam – Ward 2 Councillor (476 votes)
  • Carol Ann LeMoine – Ward 3 Councillor (451 votes)
  • Tina Kilbourne – Ward 5 Councillor (1,340 votes)
  • Jaden Hollingshead – District Councillor (2,668 votes)
  • Randy Jorgensen – Ward 4 Councillor (acclaimed)
  • Sandy Cairns – District Councillor (3,072 votes)
  • Penny Varney – District Councillor (2,823 votes)
Artist Jason Wilkins, of Peterborough, finished off a delightful caricature commissioned by Watson for his mayor’s office.

Watson thanked them and all those who ran — while noting that none of other candidates who sought office were in attendance when he asked if any of them were on hand to stand.

In addition, he said: “They deserve our round of applause and our support. I talked to most of them — and believe me their hearts were in the community.”

The mayor also recognized the members of council who will not be coming back for this term, mayor Heidi Lorenz (a no-show Tuesday), Peter Johnson, Erin Strength, Christina Hunter, Jo Morphy and Michelle Robinson — the only past councillor present last night She did not run.

Former mayor Paul Kelly 2018-22 placed the chain of office on Watson. He seems to be a bit of a mentor for the new mayor. Watson also served on council twice, once under Paisley Donaldson and when he was previously appointed a councillor by mayor John Klinck to fill a vacancy.

CAO Scott Lucas administers the oath of office to Mayor and CEO Jeff Watson, who along with most of the rest of council humourously struggled at times with the words.

Watson said in his inaugural address: “We are looking so forward to making the changes that are expected after this past election. You never change things by fighting the existing model. To change something, you build a new model that makes the existing model obsolete.”

His speech wouldn’t have been out of place at any first meeting in Ontario this.

But it was flat and failed to inspire any rounds of applause from supporters.

Even when he delivered predictable lines that should have had people out of their seats: “I want us to start by recognizing something very important. Gravenhurst is a great place to live! Gravenhurst is a great place to raise a family! Gravenhurst is a great place to operate a business! And it’s a community with an incredible future and a huge heart.”

Yet there was no mention of the Muskoka Centre property sale, which looms large over the town and council and will be a game-changer.

It may be early days jitters … and while respectful, mayor’s remarks sounded a tad trite — almost AI.

“We have so much to be proud of. Our natural surroundings, our waterfront, our neighbourhoods, our downtown, our community organizations, our volunteers — and most importantly our people. These are the things that make Gravenhurst special. They are also the reasons people choose to call this community home.

“I believe it is time to change the narrative. We should not spend all our time talking about what is wrong, what we don’t have, or what we can’t do. We need to recognize what’s right about Gravenhurst. Build on our strengths; create an environment where residents feel proud about their community and very optimistic about its future.”

Kellam, Lemoine and Jorgensen had no trouble signing first official documents confirming their election to council.

Emphasizing his obviously fiscal and conservative leanings, he added: “It doesn’t mean ignoring the challenges. Every municipality faces financial pressures, competing priorities, and difficult decisions. The cost of goods, materials, services, and infrastructure has increased significantly. Those same pressures affect every household, every local business, and every way our municipal municipality conducts its business. We have a responsibility to manage those pressures.

“Fiscal responsibility must be at the forefront of all our decisions. We need to understand where our money is going, make thoughtful investments, protect our services, and our residents. And ensure that every tax dollar delivers value to our community.

“But responsible financial management should never mean losing sight of opportunity. We must be prepared to invest in our future, maintain our municipal assets, address infrastructure and make decisions that are positive and position Gravenhurst for long-term success.

“It’s just as important,” he said “as how we work together. I believe council must be a collaborative team. Every member around the table was elected to represent the people of Gravenhurst, and every member brings different experiences, knowledge, and perspectives. Those voices deserve to be heard and respected.

“The role of the mayor is to facilitate that discussion, encourage cooperation, find common ground, and help move council forward. For the greater good. Equally important is the relationship between council and our municipal staff.”

He concluded, saying: “We need to work together, communicate openly and establish clear priorities. Council provides direction, staff bring their professional expertise and together we have an opportunity to accomplish some very meaningful things.

“Our focus must be on building a stronger, more vibrant Gravenhurst. That means continuing to support economic development, creating opportunities for local businesses, revitalizing our downtown, addressing housing needs and ensuring that our infrastructure keeps pace with the needs of a growing community.

“It also means recognizing that a great community is about much more than roads, buildings and budgets.

“It’s about people. It’s about creating opportunities for our young people to build their futures here. Supporting our seniors, helping families, welcoming newcomers, and making sure everyone feels they have a place in this community. We need to bring people together, residents, businesses, community organizations, volunteers, council and staff, all have that role to play. Our greatest accomplishments will come when we work together, rather than work in isolation.

“I want people to feel good about living here. I want our businesses to see opportunity. I want our young people to see a future here. And I want those considering moving to Gravenhurst to see a community that is welcoming, progressive, responsible and proud of what it has to offer. We don’t have to agree on everything, and in fact, healthy discussion and different perspectives make for a better decision.

“But once little decisions are made, we must move forward together and remain accountable to people who place their trust in us.

“My vision is simple. I want Gravenhurst to be a community that believes in itself.

“A community that recognizes its potential, embraces its opportunities and takes pride in the place we call home. We have the people, the resources. The history and the foundation to accomplish great things; our responsibility now is to build on that foundation.

“Let’s make this term defined, not by what divides us, but what brings us together. Not simply by the challenges we face, but by the opportunities we create.

“And above all, let’s make sure that when people talk about Gravenhurst, they talk about a community that is moving forward — that cares. And a community where people are proud to live.

“Gravenhurst is a great place to call home. Let’s work together to make it even better.”

Former Gravenhurst mayor and district chair Gord Adams and his partner Heather Davis were among more than 200 well-wishers. He said he didn’t apply for his old upper tier municipal government job.
Rob Haag and Diane Barr wish Sandy Cairns and her husband Marty the best in the Trillium Court celebration afterwards.
The evening was light-hearted and including music by the husband and wife duo of “Sonny Boy Mick & Michelle” (Stephen McPhail and Michele Goddard-McPhail). 
Gravenhurst will be marching to new drummers the next four years after nine new councillors were sworn in at the Opera House.

📧 Contact, Subscribe, Advertise

Email: news@muskokatoday.com

Mail: MuskokaTODAY.com, Box 34, Gravenhurst, ON P1P 1T5

Advertise: Email news@muskokatoday.com for rates